At one point in our lives, we’ll all
experience feelings on the spectrum of pain, grief or depression. As humans we
are susceptible to a misery that, in severe cases, can lead to self-harm and
suicide. Understanding how urgent of a problem this is, In 1993 R.E.M. devoted
a song to reaching out to the hurt, the morose and depressed. Their purpose was
to reassure the troubled, to let them know that they are not alone in the
battle against depression.
Depression
isn’t picky when choosing its victims. Depression isn’t selective to age, gender
or race. In the music video, every demographic is accounted for- the rich, the
poor, the men, the women, the religious, the atheist, the young and the dying.
In their downtime, tired internal conflicts are recited in their minds. To
portray the face of depression, they created a microcosm of the world to show
that everyone is susceptible to feeling down. By exposing this, It comforts the
depressed by letting them know they are not alone in the fight.
What makes Depression such a dangerous
illness is that not everyone recognizes it as a serious medical condition, so
it often goes untreated. There is a stigma to admitting the severity of
pessimistic feelings, which leads to the suppression of emotions and the lack
of a supporting community. This problem is addressed in the music video by
having no direct verbal communication between people. Subtitles are used
throughout the video as a tool for the viewer to see their internal monologue
and understand that they are all struggling with a conflict. Without communication,
the depressed assume they’re alone in the fight. Even in an entire highway of
depressed people, they can’t find solace in the company of others because no
one is revealing their troubles. Only when Stipe, the lead singer, reaches out
his hand to another is when people start to feel optimistic and supported. The
point of this was to encourage the troubled to “take comfort in your friends”.
R.E.M.
uses body language to exhibit the vulnerability and hesitation of the mentally
ill reaching out for aid. As Stipe walks into the traffic, his arms are crossed
over his chest and his hand protects his neck. Amy Cuddy, a Ted Talk speaker and expert on body language,
explains that these are all instinctive movements that humans do when we feel
defenseless- we constrict our bodies so we are less noticed. On the contrary,
when we are confident- we expand our bodies. When Stipe extends his hand and
expands his body he, and everyone else, gains courage to unite. The tail pipes
exhale and what was once a dreaded nuisance is now a place of rebirth and human
compassion. The traffic represents how depression can be a dominating
obstruction in a life. But, with the support of friends, it becomes clear that
happiness is attainable. All you have to do is get out of the car. You have to
get out of the car and walk, to achieve the freedom of a clear road, the
freedom of a clear life.
Mairead, this post is fantastic. You have tackled a provocative issue and found a great music video. You also write very well. I found this post to be engaging and instructive. Thank you. I have to be honest, I have heard this song a million times - I've always loved it - but I have never seen this video. When I looked at the draft of your first paragraph, I did not know that the video was going to feature traffic. I thought you had created that yourself. Now I see the connection more clearly. Your analysis is great because you address all of the key rhetorical decisions that R.E.M. makes - the traffic, the subtitles, the lack of communication between passengers, and the ultimate escape. I especially like that you address Stipe's body language in terms of the explanation that Cuddy provides. Great stuff.
ReplyDeleteThere is only one sentence that I want you to look at: "This problem is addressed in the music video by having no direct verbal communication between people." This sentence really doesn't make much sense to me. I think you might have been better off avoiding the passive voice.
Regardless, you write very well in this post.